Family Jewels blog.

Archive for the ‘Moral Question’ Category

Is It Ever Okay to Spank Your Kids?

Photo courtesy of HA! Designs Artbyheather via Flickr (CC)

By Catherine Connors, author of the blog HerBadMother.com. 

It was only once, but I still feel guilty about it. We—she and I and her little brother—were leaving a grocery store. She’d been throwing a fit and making a scene and I was doing the best I could to manage her under extremely trying circumstances. As we neared the sidewalk, she pulled away and grabbed the stroller with her brother in it and yanked it toward the street, shrieking in that manic way that is the hallmark of fit-throwing three-year-olds everywhere. There was no time for reasoning or arguing or cajoling. There was no time for shouting or bargaining or threatening. I had to stop her, and I had to do it immediately. So I grabbed her and I pulled her, struggling and shrieking, back to me and I spanked her.

It was the kind of spank that well-meaning parents refer to as a “swat on the bottom.” It wasn’t hard, it wasn’t repeated and it was only meant to startle her out of her fit. It worked. I didn’t like it, but it worked. She stopped and blinked and her lower lip quivered and I said, “Honey, I need you to stop,” and I explained why I’d done what I had. To this day I don’t know what I could have done differently. But I don’t know that that matters. What matters is, I found myself in a challenging parenting situation in which I had to act quickly and the action that I took was one that I had sworn I’d never take and I just have to make my peace with that because chances are that I’ll find myself in such a situation again.

When I wrote on my blog about the incident, I expressed regret that it happened, but I also said I felt that I’d had little choice and that I firmly believed that I needed to forgive myself for it. I added I would be making my best effort, in the future, to resist passing judgment on any other parents who found themselves in similar circumstances. I hoped, I said, that other parents would do me the same courtesy and not judge me.

To read about the reaction Connors received to her blog, and the rest of the article, click here. Have any feedback? Tell us what you think in the comments below.

This article and other hot button topics including infidelity, teaching morality in schools, sex, lying to your kids and how TV and video games are actually good for your kids are all in the April 2010 issue on newsstands March 15th.

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

Cash For Grades: One School’s Fundraising Strategy

photo sxc.hu

photo sxc.hu

According to reports, a middle school in North Carolina has given up on selling chocolate bars and is now informing parents that a $20 donation to the school will get a student 20 test points—10 extra points on two tests (of their choice). Those extra 10 points could possibly raise a failing grade to a D or a B to an A.

Apparently the plan was endorsed by the principal after it was brought forward by the Parent Advisory Council. Their argument is that one or two graded tests are not enough to make a difference during the entire year. State education officials, however, are none too pleased, saying it sends the wrong message to kids. Plus, kids from families who can’t afford the donation won’t have the same advantage.

So what to do you think? An innovative fundraiser or poor ethical lesson?

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

Are Little Girls Clothes Way Too Sexy?

In the age of super low-rise jeans, bikini-clad girls in music videos and sex as a powerful marketing tool, where do we draw the line? It seems the acceptable age for the thong-wearing, mid-drift-bearing girl keeps getting younger and younger. Do you let your daughter wear sexy clothes? At what age do you think it’s okay to dress provocatively? The experts at Momversation weigh in on the issue.

.

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

Momversation Monday: Is it Right to Discipline Someone Else’s Child?

There have been a few posts here on Family Jewels about how you deal with “that mom” and “that kid,” and it looks like we’re not the only ones who’ve taken an interest in the topic. This week, the panelists at Momversation discuss whether or not it’s okay to discipline someone else’s child. Disciplining your own children is one thing, but what happens if your little one’s friend is misbehaving and their parent is not around? What would you do?

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

Would You Bring Your Child to a Protest?

Photo by Lise Varette

Photo by Lise Varette

When it comes to kids, the whole world is a classroom. Little ones are prone to taking in everything around them, asking questions and searching for answers. As parents, we’re lucky to be their first teachers, encouraging their curiosity and fueling their imaginations. But when it comes to public protests, is it better for children to be active participants, or passive observers?

On Mother’s Day, Tamil protesters here in Toronto stormed the Gardiner Expressway  (a major highway in and out of the downtown core) in an effort to bring awareness to a cause that they are extremely passionate about (you can read more about it here). It was one of many recent demonstrations that involved thousands of Tamils and Tamil-Canadians of all ages. And although we respect their passion and their right to voice their concerns about the atrocities that are taking place in Sri Lanka, there was one thing that we found particularly troubling about the Mother’s Day demonstration: the presence of children, especially those in strollers. It got us to thinking, when it comes to taking part in a protest, where and when do you draw the line as far as your child’s safety is concerned? How do you teach your kids that it’s important to stand up for what you believe in, while also upholding the law and staying safe?

Interested in teaching your child more about activism? Check out our article on raising an activist child.

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

Flu fears

piglets

So here is my dilemma. Our neighbours are currently on vacation in Mexico (Mayan Riviera). My daughter and their son play together almost every evening. With all the news about Swine Flu, I don’t think I will be letting them play together for at least a week when they return. The problem is that he is not old enough for school yet and stays at home with his dad. My girl goes to JK and daycare. Should the little guy get sick and pass it on to my daughter, she’d be the one infecting the neighbourhood. I feel bad for him because he plays with all the kids on the street and I know he won’t understand why he’s not having any play dates. Am I overreacting here?

Robin, CF’s senior editor

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

Guest Post: Misadventures in Mothering

While I’ve been over here blogging for Family Jewels this week, I’ve been plumbing my own archives and putting up some of my favourite posts back on Postcards from the Mothership. The good thing about having been a blogger for more than four years is that I have very deep archives—more than 1300 posts! The bad thing about that is that sometimes I think I’ve said everything worth saying.

Since I’m in recycling mode anyway, I thought I’d bring this old post over here, too. It’s a fun topic, and I think that having a good sense of humour and the ability to poke fun at yourself is one of the most important items in the parental tool-kit. This post was originally written in 2006, when Tristan was four and Simon was two. I was writing in response to another blogger’s post about parenting calamities and disasters, in the wake of Britney Spears’ very unfortunate and very public parenting foibles that summer.

***
It was one of those blazingly hot summer days and both boys had been stubbornly nap-resistant, only falling asleep in the back seat of the car on our way to run an errand across town.

I only had to run in and out. It was a tiny little shop and they were actually holding what I needed behind the counter—I would be three minutes at most. For the first time ever, I contemplated leaving the boys in the car, weighing the danger factor (practically none) and the panic factor should one of them wake up and find me not there (marginal, as both were snoring) versus the annoyance factor of waking them up and carting two sweaty, cranky preschoolers in with me for my one-minute errand, and then facing the rest of the day with their slumber-interrupted crankiness.sleeping

I parked in the shade, debated for a long minute—and made the wrong choice. I figured I’d leave them in the car, and leave the car running so the air conditioning would stay on, but lock the doors and take my electronic remote key fob with me. They would never actually be out of my line of sight.

I ran in, concluded my transaction, and ran out again. The whole thing took maybe 180 seconds. I felt a little guilty, because I know better than to do something dumb like that, but it was a calculated risk and I told myself I would never do it again as I pushed the button to unlock the doors.

And nothing happened.

I pressed the button again, and a few more times for good measure. I tried the door, in case it miraculously unlocked itself in my absence, and tried to lift the back hatch. In desperation, I tried to use the remote on the back hatch, closing my eyes and wishing with all my heart to hear the familiar thunk of the trunk release when I pushed the button. Silence.

Did you see it coming? Did you know that if the engine is running, your electronic remote key fob doesn’t work? Great safety feature, isn’t it? Unless, of course, you have locked your sleeping preschoolers in the running car, that is.

All the air evaporated out of my lungs as I realized what I had done. I stood blinking stupidly at the boys in the back seat, imagining the phone conversation—oh look, there’s the phone right there on the front seat where I left it—that I would have with Beloved. I pictured police with slim jims called to unlock the doors and liberate my now-awake and terrified children. I envisioned child protective services becoming involved, and the media, too, because you always see the story about the person who leaves their dog in the mall parking lot in 30C heat, so surely to god they’re going to run with the story of the dumb-ass mother who locks her babies in her car. On purpose.

After a full minute of standing rooted in full-out panic, I realized I had another option. Tristan knows how to open the door. I tapped gently on the window near his lolling head, stage-whispering his name. Nothing. I pounded on the glass with all my might and bellowed his name, and he slept blissfully on. I finally—FINALLY!—managed to get his eyelids to flutter open, and he regarded me with unfocused confusion (I can only laugh when I picture what my face must have looked like!) before trying to drift back to sleep. I thumped the window a few more times, and finally roused him enough to convince him to unlock his door.

My legs were rubbery by the time I dropped into the driver’s seat and pulled out of the parking lot. A few deep breaths later, I could almost see the potential humour in the situation, but mostly I was grateful that outing my stupidity would be my choice, and not foisted upon me.

So, I’ve showed you mine. ‘Fess up – what parenting misadventure made you grateful that the paparazzi weren’t lurking in the bushes ready to broadcast the whole thing on Entertainment Tonight? We all have our “worst parent” moment—what’s yours?

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

Moral Question: Parent Blogging in 10 Years

teen1

Blogging about my blankie? Not cool, Mom!

The generation of kids toddling around right now is the first to be blogged about to such a thorough degree. As parents record all the details of their kids’ lives (often for the benefit and entertainment of others), we wonder what will happen when this generation of kids grows up. Will there be a colossal backlash from kids who feel they’ve been exploited, despite our attempts to be respectful and protect their identities? Will our kids refuse to blog about their own in protest? Will mom and dad blogs become a thing of the past? Or will this generation of kids simply look on their parents’ blogs as we look on photo albums or memory boxes? Will a parental blog be just one more noise in the cacophony of personal information made public?

Our crystal ball is on the fritz—will anyone share their predictions?

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

Moral Question: Moms Behaving Badly Online

Photo by Getty Images

Photo by Getty Images

We couldn’t help but notice some of the drama that unfolded last week in the comment sections of a few popular mom blogs. We’ve mentioned in the past that breastfeeding is a heated topic, but this time things may have gone a bit too far. The culprits? A selection of commenters who had some very nasty things to say (particularly when using the handle “Anonymous”).

As much as we might like to vent our frustrations about a particular topic, it’s important to keep in mind that the things we say to each other—even anonymously, via the internet—can really sting. While we love the fact that the Internet has given parents the opportunity to share their experiences and engage in discussion with each other, it’s very disappointing when a potentially great conversation quickly degrades into a catty episode of name calling and cyber bullying.

But the bigger question, we think, is this: How can we tell our children not to behave this way with their friends if we can’t act civilly towards each other as adults? What kind of example are we setting with our online behaviour?

We want to know—what do you think about anonymous commenting online? Would you (or do you) comment anonymously? Why or why not?


  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

To Feed or Not to Feed: A Breastfeeding Dilemma

Photo by Vladislav Gansovsky/Fotolia

Photo by Vladislav Gansovsky/Fotolia

As a member of the online community, we tend to keep an eye out for hot topics of discussion amongst moms on the web. Over the past couple of days, we’ve noticed that one topic in particular has been quite… heated.

Without getting into details or naming names (and we would respectfully ask that our commenters follow that lead), the issue of breastfeeding a baby that is not your own has recently taken centre stage in the world of mom blogs. Now, it’s certainly not a new issue—in fact, it wasn’t that long ago that we blogged about Salma Hayek feeding another woman’s baby while on a humanitarian mission in Sierra Leone—but it is an issue that stirs up some very strong opinions and even stronger emotions.

While the practice of using wet nurses goes back to antiquity, in our modern society it is not nearly as common as it once was. With the introduction of baby formula, the practice of wet nursing became practically obsolete. In North America, where the issue of breastfeeding is a passionate and often polarizing topic, the practice of wet nursing evokes some very strong reactions.

We can’t help but wonder: as mothers, as friends of other mothers, do you feel that breastfeeding another woman’s child is wrong? Is it something that you would consider doing for someone else? Would you allow a friend to breastfeed your child?

  • comment on this postComment
  • RSS Feed IconGet The RSS

advertisement
Twitter Feed

follow us on Twitter

NEWSLETTER
Join Us

Sign-up here to receive our FREE e-newsletter - exclusive content, offers, recipes and more!

advertisement Luxe for Less 20msc Bake Sale Guide March Break
advertisement
Special Messages
advertisement