Top Tomato Sauce Picks

One pasta-loving family puts store-bought tomato sauce to the test

Originally published October, 2007

By Hannah Bank

Photo by Carlo Mendoza

Using off-the-shelf tomato sauce over cooked pasta is a fast and easy dinnertime solution, but is it healthy? That depends, says Toronto registered dietitian Shauna Lindzon. “While tomato sauce contains vitamin C, beta carotene, potassium, fibre and lycopene [a powerful antioxidant that helps fight a growing list of cancers], read the nutrient profile and ingredients, and avoid high levels of sodium [no more than 400 mg per ½ cup], sugar and saturated fat hidden in the sauce.” Here’s how some popular brands fared with Terry and Stephanie Dietrich and their three kids (twins Nicholas and Stuart, 8, and Rachel, 4) in Etobicoke, Ont. Buon appetito!

a - family fave

Healthy Choice Traditional
60 calories, 0 g fat, 0 g cholesterol, 400 mg sodium, 13 g carbs (3 g fibre, 8 g sugar), 2 g protein per ½ cup (125 mL). $3 per 700 mL jar

Our testers gave this sauce top marks for flavour and health. “It’s yummy and tastes just like at the restaurant,” says 8-year-old Stuart. Twin brother Nicholas was happily surprised by what he describes as “a zing at the end.” The verdict: Moderate in fibre and low in sodium, this is a smart choice. Because it’s fat-free, add a fat source such as lean ground meat to maximize lycopene absorption.

b- - odd aftertaste

Simply Natural Organic Marinara
50 calories, 2 g fat, 0 mg cholesterol, 490 mg sodium, 8 g carbs (2 g fibre, 3 g sugar), 1 g protein per 120 mL serving. $5 per 739 mL jar

Stephanie was disappointed—“the jar looked so delicious but I didn’t like the taste.” The kids agree that it was “too tomatoey and the aftertaste is weird.” The verdict: This sauce has good nutritional value for consumers who opt for organic products. If you find that the sauce has a strong acidic flavour, try adding some cooked vegetables like red peppers or squash to cut down on the tartness and sneak in more vitamins.

a+ - Heart Safe

Classico Tomato & Basil
60 calories, 1 g fat, 0 mg cholesterol, 320 mg sodium, 11 g carbs (2 g fibre, 6 g sugar), 2 g protein per 125 mL serving. $4 per 700 mL jar

Aside from the “tomato chunks” that the kids tend to pick out, this sauce is a staple. Mom and Dad love it because there is no added refined sugar in the ingredient list (the only sugar comes from natural sources). The verdict: This sauce is your best bet. It’s low in sodium and sugar, and the only sauce that lists good-for-you olive oil as an ingredient. Finally, a heart-friendly choice that tastes fabulous, too.